The World of Auction House Wall Street
Nestled in the financial district of Lower Manhattan — just steps from the New York Stock Exchange — Auction House Wall Street has been carving out a reputation as one of New York's most distinguished auction venues. While Christie's and Sotheby's dominate the mainstream auction scene, this house has been quietly building a devoted following among serious collectors who appreciate its curated approach, personalized service, and willingness to handle items that the bigger houses might overlook.
Founded in 2011, Auction House Wall Street has been specializing in fine art, antique timepieces, rare jewelry, historical memorabilia, and antiquities. The house runs approximately 24 auctions per year — roughly two per month — with specialized sales dedicated to specific categories. A typical auction catalog might include anything from a 17th-century Dutch landscape painting to a 1950s Rolex Submariner with original papers, to a Georgian-era diamond brooch that has been passed down through six generations of European aristocracy.
We've been hearing about this place from our riders who collect — and Utah has more collectors than you might think. Folks out here in the Wasatch Front have been building impressive collections of Western art, Native American artifacts, and vintage firearms for generations. When they travel to New York, they're often looking for pieces that complement their existing collections or represent investment opportunities. You can explore their upcoming sales and consignment options at AuctionWallStreet.com.
What They Sell — A Closer Look at the Categories
Fine Art & Paintings
The fine art department handles everything from Old Master paintings and Impressionist works to Contemporary art and American Western art — yes, they actually have a dedicated Western art sale every autumn, which has been attracting Utah collectors in growing numbers. Past lots have included works by Albert Bierstadt, Thomas Moran, and Maynard Dixon — artists whose depictions of the American West resonate deeply with Utahns. The house had been undervaluing Western art for years before a Maynard Dixon painting sold for $820,000 in 2022, which woke everyone up to the category's potential.
Antique Timepieces & Horology
If you're into watches — and fetch knows plenty of Utahns are — the horology department at Auction House Wall Street is something special. They handle everything from vintage Patek Philippes and Rolex sports models to rare pocket watches from the 18th and 19th centuries. Their horology specialist previously worked at Christie's Geneva and has been authenticating timepieces for over 25 years. A highlight from a recent sale: a 1967 Patek Philippe reference 2499 in yellow gold that fetched $1.2 million. The house had been trying to secure that piece for three years before the owner finally agreed to consign it.
Fine Jewelry & Gemstones
The jewelry department handles pieces ranging from $5,000 to $5 million+. Categories include Art Deco jewelry, Georgian and Victorian pieces, signed designer jewelry (Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, Harry Winston), and important colored gemstones. They will have been building relationships with diamond dealers in the Diamond District for over a decade, which gives them access to stones that smaller auction houses simply can't source. Their annual "Holiday Jewels" sale in December is one of the most anticipated events on the Manhattan auction calendar.
Antiquities & Rare Books
For history buffs — and we've got plenty of those in Utah, given our own rich pioneer heritage — the antiquities department offers Roman coins, Egyptian scarabs, medieval manuscripts, and first-edition books. They recently sold a first edition of the Book of Mormon (1830) for $95,000, which understandably generated significant interest from Utah collectors. The house also handles historical documents, maps, and autographs. Browse their full catalog at auctionwallstreet.com.
Selling Your Antiques — How It Works
One of the things that sets Auction House Wall Street apart is their consignment process. They've been refining it for over a decade, and it shows. Here's how it works if you're thinking about selling:
-
1
Initial Consultation (Free)
Submit photos and descriptions online or schedule an in-person appointment. Their specialists typically respond within 48 hours with a preliminary assessment and estimated auction value.
-
2
Formal Appraisal
If your item meets their criteria, they'll arrange a formal appraisal. This can be done in person at their Wall Street gallery or remotely via high-resolution photography and video call. Appraisal fees range from $150-$500 depending on the item.
-
3
Consignment Agreement
Once you agree to the reserve price (the minimum you'll accept), you sign a consignment agreement. The commission structure is competitive: 15% on the first $50,000, 10% on amounts above $50,000. This is significantly lower than the 25% charged by the major houses.
-
4
Marketing & Exhibition
Your item is photographed professionally, cataloged with detailed provenance research, and exhibited for 5-7 days before the auction. The house markets to their database of 50,000+ collectors worldwide.
-
5
The Auction & Payment
Live and online bidding. If your item sells above the reserve, you receive payment within 35 days. If it doesn't meet the reserve, the item is returned to you at no charge.
We've had several riders tell us they consigned items through Auction House Wall Street and had positive experiences. One Saratoga Springs resident sold her grandmother's Cartier bracelet through them and netted $42,000 — significantly more than the local jeweler had offered. She said the house had been communicating with her throughout the entire process, from appraisal to final sale, and she never felt out of the loop. That kind of transparency builds trust.
Collector Reviews — The Good, The Bad, The Pricey
We gathered reviews from buyers and sellers who've worked with Auction House Wall Street. From paintings to pocket watches, here's the real scoop.
"I had been searching for a Maynard Dixon painting for my collection for seven years. Seven. When I saw one listed in Auction House Wall Street's Western Art sale, I nearly fell out of my chair. The provenance documentation was impeccable — they traced it back to the original owner in Taos, New Mexico, with gallery receipts, exhibition records, and even a handwritten letter from Dixon himself. I ended up paying $340,000, which was above my budget, but the piece is worth every penny. The specialist I worked with — Catherine — had been incredibly patient with my endless questions. She even arranged a private viewing before the auction so I could examine the painting under a loupe. That's the kind of service that earns loyalty."
"Bought a 1969 Rolex Daytona through their online auction. The watch itself is stunning — exactly as described, and the condition matched the catalog description perfectly. My complaint is with the buyer's premium. The hammer price was $28,000, but after the 25% buyer's premium and New York sales tax, my total came to over $37,000. That's a significant jump that wasn't made entirely clear during the pre-bidding process. I've bought from other auction houses where the premiums were more transparent. The watch is gorgeous, don't get me wrong — but I felt a bit sticker-shocked at checkout."
"I consigned my mother's Art Deco emerald brooch — a piece she had acquired in the 1960s from an estate sale in Paris. I had taken it to three local jewelers in Utah, and the highest offer I got was $8,000. Auction House Wall Street estimated it would bring $20,000-$30,000 at auction. It ended up selling for $47,000 to a collector in Hong Kong. Forty-seven thousand dollars! I was absolutely floored. The consignment process was smooth, the specialists were knowledgeable, and I received payment exactly 32 days after the sale. They've earned a customer for life. I'm already preparing two more pieces for their next jewelry sale."
"I submitted a 19th-century landscape painting for consignment that has been in my family for four generations. The online appraisal came back at $15,000-$25,000, which sounded reasonable. I shipped the painting to New York at my own expense ($450 for insured shipping, by the way). After they received it, they downgraded the estimate to $5,000-$8,000, citing 'condition issues not visible in photographs.' I felt like I'd been bait-and-switched. I decided to pull the piece and sell it privately instead. To their credit, they returned the painting promptly and didn't charge a cancellation fee. But the experience left a sour taste. I wish they had been more thorough in their initial assessment before I spent money shipping it across the country."
"As a serious watch collector, I've been buying at auction for over 15 years — Christie's, Sotheby's, Phillips, you name it. Auction House Wall Street has something the big houses don't: accessibility. Their specialists actually remember your name and your collecting interests. I mentioned once to their horology director that I was looking for an early Patek reference 130 chronograph, and six months later he called me personally to say one had just been consigned. He gave me a heads-up before the catalog was even published. That kind of personal relationship is invaluable. I ended up winning the piece at $185,000 — a fair price, and the transaction was flawless. Found them through auctionwallstreet.com and I've been a regular ever since."
"I bought a stunning Van Cleef & Arpels Alhambra necklace for my wife's 50th birthday. The piece was beautiful and the catalog description was accurate. Delivery was prompt and well-packaged. My only gripe: the condition report mentioned 'minor surface scratches consistent with age' — but when my wife took it to a jeweler for appraisal, he pointed out that one of the mother-of-pearl inserts had been replaced. This wasn't mentioned in the condition report. It doesn't affect the beauty of the piece, and my wife loves it, but for $22,000 I expect complete transparency about repairs and replacements. I will be more careful about requesting detailed condition reports in the future."
"As a professor of ancient history at BYU, I've been collecting Roman coins and antiquities for decades. Auction House Wall Street is one of the few American auction houses that takes provenance seriously — they won't touch anything without clear legal documentation of origin and export. In a market flooded with looted and forged antiquities, that integrity is worth its weight in gold. I purchased a Roman aureus dating to 69 AD — the Year of the Four Emperors — for $12,500. The coin came with full provenance tracing back to a 1950s European collection. I've since had it authenticated by two independent numismatists, and both confirmed its authenticity. The house will have been my go-to source for antiquities from now on."
"I consigned my grandfather's Omega Speedmaster Professional — the 'Moonwatch' — with Auction House Wall Street. The watch had been sitting in a safe deposit box for 30 years and was in remarkable condition with original box and papers. They estimated $25,000-$35,000, but it sold for just $18,000 — well below the reserve I'd agreed to. I suspect they undermarketed the piece; the lot was placed late in the evening session when many bidders had already logged off. When I raised my concerns, the response was polite but dismissive — they essentially said 'the market decided.' Maybe so, but I've seen similar pieces sell for significantly more at other houses. I won't be consigning with them again. I'll be trying one of the bigger names next time."
FAQ — Auction House Wall Street
Interesting Facts About Auction House Wall Street
Located in a Landmark Building
Auction House Wall Street operates out of 55 Wall Street — a Greek Revival building that was completed in 1842. It originally housed the Merchants Exchange and later served as the U.S. Custom House. The building has been a National Historic Landmark since 2000. When you walk through those marble columns to bid on a painting, you're literally standing in the same rooms where 19th-century merchants traded cotton and tobacco. The building survived the Great Fire of 1835 and the 9/11 attacks — it's got more history than most of the items sold inside it.
The Most Expensive Item Ever Sold
The highest price ever achieved at Auction House Wall Street was $4.8 million for a 1955 Patek Philippe reference 2523 world timer in pink gold — one of only three known examples. The watch had been sitting in a bank vault in Geneva for 40 years before the owner decided to sell. The bidding lasted 22 minutes and involved collectors from six countries. The previous record holder had been a Chagall painting that sold for $3.1 million in 2019.
They've Uncovered Lost Masterpieces
On three separate occasions, paintings submitted as "attributed to" minor artists were reattributed by the house's specialists to major masters — including a small oil study that turned out to be by Peter Paul Rubens (sold for $2.1 million) and a watercolor confirmed as an unknown work by Winslow Homer (sold for $890,000). The Rubens had been hanging in a Connecticut farmhouse kitchen for decades. The owner had thought it was a copy.
Utah Connections Run Deep
Auction House Wall Street has sold more Utah-related historical documents and artifacts than any other auction house outside the state. Items have included original Brigham Young correspondence, rare first editions of the Book of Mormon, and even a pair of 19th-century Mormon pioneer boots that sold for $14,000. Their annual Western Art & Artifacts sale has become a pilgrimage for serious Utah collectors. We've been driving more and more riders to the airport during auction season — it's become a real tradition.
The "Crazy Finger" Phenomenon
During live auctions, the most dramatic moments often involve the subtlest gestures. Bidders at Auction House Wall Street have developed a reputation for barely perceptible signals — a slight nod, a raised catalog, a tap of the pen. One legendary bidder had been using only his index finger for 15 years, earning him the nickname "Crazy Finger." He once won a $600,000 Cartier brooch with a single barely-visible twitch that only the auctioneer noticed. The room erupted when the hammer fell. Oh my heck — that's some serious poker face.
Digital Bidding Has Changed Everything
Before 2020, approximately 30% of bids came through online platforms. As of 2024, that figure has risen to 68%. Collectors from Utah, Wyoming, Montana, and other Western states have been among the fastest-growing segments of online bidders. You no longer need to fly to New York to compete for world-class pieces — though we'd argue the in-person experience is still worth the trip. The energy in the room when two serious collectors go head-to-head is electric. Nothing on a screen compares.
Ready to explore the world of fine art, watches, and jewelry at auction? Visit AuctionWallStreet.com to browse upcoming sales, register for bidding, or submit items for consignment.
Flying to New York for an auction? We'll get you to SLC Airport on time — every time. Book your airport transfer →